What should I select Medicare Advantage or Medicare Supplement?

Written by

This is one of the biggest decisions people face when enrolling in Medicare.
The right choice depends on your health needs, budget, and lifestyle. Here’s a clear side-by-side
comparison:

Medicare Advantage (Part C)
✔ Pros:

  • Usually has lower monthly premiums (sometimes $0).
  • Bundles hospital (A), medical (B), and often prescription drugs (D).
  • Many plans include extra benefits like dental, vision, hearing, and gym memberships.
  • Annual out-of-pocket maximum for medical costs (Original Medicare does not have
    this).

✘ Cons:

  • Network restrictions: HMO plans require in-network doctors; PPOs allow out-of-network
    but costs more.
  • Referrals may be required for specialists.
  • Costs vary by service (copays, coinsurance).
  • Coverage usually limited to the U.S. (not suitable for frequent travelers abroad).

Best for: People who want lower premiums, are comfortable using a provider network, and
value extra benefits.

Medicare Supplement (Medigap)

✔ Pros:

  • Lets you see any doctor or hospital that accepts Medicare — no networks.
  • Very predictable costs (small or no bills after Medicare pays).
  • Works nationwide (great for travelers within the U.S.).
  • Some plans (like Plan G) cover nearly all out-of-pocket costs except the Part B deductible.
  • Some policies include foreign emergency coverage

✘ Cons:

  • Monthly premiums are higher (often $100–$200+ depending on age and state).
  • Does not include prescription drug coverage (you must buy a separate Part D plan).
  • Does not cover dental, vision, or hearing.

Best for: People who want maximum flexibility, travel frequently, or prefer to avoid surprise
medical bills.

Key Decision Points

  • Budget: If you want low monthly costs → Medicare Advantage. If you want predictable
    medical bills even if you get sick → Medigap.
  • Doctors & hospitals: If your doctors are in a Medicare Advantage network, that can
    work. If you want the freedom to see any Medicare provider, choose a Medigap plan.
  • Travel: Frequent U.S. or international travel → Medigap is usually beer.
  • Extra perks (dental/vision): Only Medicare Advantage includes these.

A good rule of thumb:

  • Healthier, budget-conscious, and OK with networks? Medicare Advantage.
  • Want the most freedom, travel a lot, or expect high medical use? Medigap.
×

Comments are closed.